The more I use (or “try” to use) Google Wave, the more I think this new Google‘s communication and collaboration tool is at a too early stage of its development to be released to a wider audience. Here is why.
No realtime
In a world that is heading towards everything realtime, Google Wave (at this stage) is not. I have 22 waves open in my Google Wave account and I wouldn’t ever use them or a new one to start a collaboration session with one or more of my contacts. Why? They wouldn’t see my request when I need them to.
I made the following experiment: I tried to contact one of my friends on Twitter, by Email and by starting a new Wave. I asked him something that needed an immediate feedback and for which Google Wave would have been a great and effective tool to respond. He responded to the email after 25 minutes, Twitter after 1 hour (not addicted to Twitter) and Wave… well, my message is still there… without any response.
No alerts
This point is strictly connected to the first one. Unless you have Wave open, you don’t have any way to be alerted by any kind of activity in your Wave account. This should be sorted out very easily through some kind of widget, browser plugin, (for Mac) Growl notification or something like that. Anyway, at least during this first stage, an email notification would have been much appreciated in order to get people used to this tool. Someone is doing that, though.
What a mess!
In my Wave inbox I have a wave involving 73 participants and over 180 messages. How easy is keeping up with every message? I tried and gave up. Very difficult and in this case an old, well known forum would have offered better results. A moderation system should be introduced, too, otherwise some waves could led to unexpected and unwanted results…
What do you think? This is a someway provocative post because, despite I’m an eager early adopter of any kind of new technology internet related, I find Google Wave to be half backed and, IMHO, not ready for the prime time. Yes, it’s a preview that is making the internet community buzz a lot and I’m sure Google will learn a lot from this buzz, but it’s not going to be something I’m gonna use continuously.
What about you?
P.S. stay tuned for the next post about Wave where I’ll list three applications for using Google Wave at its best… 
Related articles by Zemanta
- How To Get Started With Google Wave – Part I: Basics (bloggingot.com)
- Google Wave Adds “Follow” Feature (mashable.com)
- Google rolls out Wave to 100,000 early users (tissuepathology.typepad.com)
- Following Google Wave Docs (blogoscoped.com)
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=23def2a3-e68e-4d5d-835d-bd71ab89be01)
Why I run my blog on Thesis Wordpress Theme
Thesis gives my blog a very professional look with very clean, easy-to-read layout and SEO friendly design. Take a look at my post explaining why I chose Thesis for my blog. Get your Thesis Theme today!
{ 3 comments… read them below or add one }
Google Wave has been a disappointment so far to us users, but I think Google purposefully threw this unfinished product out there for everybody to figure out how to use it best. I don't think we have discovered its best use yet. Twitter also evolved and improved according to how users use it. Of course when Twitter was launched there were very few social/collaboration platforms out there, and the early adopters flocked to it quickly. Traction is a now problem with Google Wave, especially when even the geekiest early adopters are not excited about it.
It's hard to rate the effectiveness of google wave right now, since it's a closed preview.
While reading your post I wondered if you used a mail notification gadget? (I guess you're using growl) and how much time you spend looking through your mail inbox?. I guess, when Wave goes public, there will be a lot of widgets and stuff to alert you when you get a new wave.
Recently I got into wave, and like many, I got struck thinking “what I do now?”. I mean, I only have like 3 or 4 contacts at most. I started a wave with one just to try it out, and didn't had to wait much until he answered. But when I started waving with some other friend, well, I'm still waiting for the answer. Just like you and your friend.
It's hard to rate the effectiveness of google wave right now, since it's a closed preview.
While reading your post I wondered if you used a mail notification gadget? (I guess you're using growl) and how much time you spend looking through your mail inbox?. I guess, when Wave goes public, there will be a lot of widgets and stuff to alert you when you get a new wave.
Recently I got into wave, and like many, I got struck thinking “what I do now?”. I mean, I only have like 3 or 4 contacts at most. I started a wave with one just to try it out, and didn't had to wait much until he answered. But when I started waving with some other friend, well, I'm still waiting for the answer. Just like you and your friend.